- ABoth statements together are needed (neither alone is sufficient)
- BStatement II alone is sufficient but Statement I alone is not
- CStatement I alone is sufficient but Statement II alone is not
- DEither statement alone is sufficient
Step-by-Step Solution
I leaves D and E unplaced; II leaves B and C unplaced. Together, D > A > B, A > C > E, so D is taller than everyone, making D the tallest.
Answer: A) Both statements together are needed (neither alone is sufficient)