- AStatement I alone is sufficient but Statement II alone is not
- BEither statement alone is sufficient
- CStatement II alone is sufficient but Statement I alone is not
- DBoth statements together are needed (neither alone is sufficient)
Step-by-Step Solution
From I alone, P is taller than Q and R but S is unknown — not sufficient. From II alone, only S > P is known — not sufficient. Combining both: S > P > Q and P > R, so S is the tallest. Both together are sufficient.
Answer: D) Both statements together are needed (neither alone is sufficient)