Practice30Create account

A state health department found that among patients admitted with severe burns, the death rate is markedly higher at the largest and best-equipped hospital in the capital than at the smaller hospitals in the surrounding towns. Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain this finding?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe smaller hospitals send on to the large hospital any patient whose burns are extensive or complicated, keeping only the milder cases themselves
  • BThe large hospital has more beds than any of the smaller hospitals
  • CBurns at the large hospital are treated in a specialised unit
  • DThe smaller hospitals charge lower fees than the large hospital

Step-by-Step Solution

The two death rates are calculated over quite different groups of patients. If the worst cases are funnelled to the large hospital while the milder ones stay behind, the large hospital's higher rate reflects the severity of the cases it receives rather than the quality of its care. Bed count, a specialised unit and fee levels do nothing to explain why more of its patients die.
Answer: A) The smaller hospitals send on to the large hospital any patient whose burns are extensive or complicated, keeping only the milder cases themselves

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

Since a construction company began issuing high-quality safety harnesses to workers at…Farmers in a district harvested their largest onion crop in a decade this season, yet…A public library reports that the number of books issued to members for home use has…A city bus operator released a mobile application that shows passengers exactly when the…Passage: Rooftop solar water heaters installed in the town have cut household…