Practice30Create account

A town council is considering replacing the old vapour lamps on its streets with light-emitting diode lamps. An engineer argues that the change will cut the council's yearly spending on street lighting even though the new lamps cost more to buy, because ______. Which of the following best completes the engineer's reasoning?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • Athe new lamps are made by several manufacturers within the country
  • Bresidents have complained that some streets are poorly lit after dark
  • Cthe new lamps draw far less electricity for the same light and last several times as long before they must be replaced
  • Dthe lamps now in use on the streets were fitted more than fifteen years ago

Step-by-Step Solution

The claim to be supported is that a higher purchase price still leads to lower yearly spending. Only lower running cost and a longer life can do that, since together they cut both the electricity bill and the frequency of replacement, outweighing the one-time extra cost. The number of manufacturers, the complaints about dark streets and the age of the present lamps say nothing about what the council will spend.
Answer: C) the new lamps draw far less electricity for the same light and last several times as long before they must be replaced

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A publisher found that when it put the first chapter of a novel on its website free of…A hospital wants to shorten the time patients wait to see a doctor in its outpatient…A dairy cooperative proposes to pay its member farmers a bonus on milk delivered before…A ward office plans to put a community compost bin at the end of every lane so that…A grocery chain plans to put four self-service billing counters in each of its stores so…