- AVisitors who took a card and filled it in do not differ in their taste from the far greater number of visitors who did not
- BThe show will be held on the same ground next year as it was held on this year
- CRose plants cost a grower less to bring to the show than plants of other kinds
- DMore visitors will come to the show next year than came to it this year
Step-by-Step Solution
The organisers propose to lay out the whole show for next year's visitors on the strength of 700 cards that a self-chosen minority of this year's visitors put in a box. The step holds only if the card-fillers stand for the visitors, and there is every reason they might not: the enthusiast who already grows roses will stop and write, while the family walking through will not. Deny the assumption and the 700 record the taste of a hobbyist fringe. The ground on which the show is held and the number of visitors expected bear on where and how large the show will be, not on what should fill it. What a rose costs a grower to bring bears on the cost of the plan, and a plan may be cheap and still be built on the wrong 700 people.
Answer: A) Visitors who took a card and filled it in do not differ in their taste from the far greater number of visitors who did not