Practice30Create account

A chain of three eye clinics reports that the average time a patient waits before being seen fell from 50 minutes to 38 minutes over the year, and its managing partner concludes that the chain's clinics are now working faster than they were. Which of the following is an assumption on which the partner's conclusion depends?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe share of the chain's patients seen at its slowest clinic was not appreciably smaller in the second year than in the first
  • BEach of the three clinics saw more patients in the second year than in the first
  • CNo patient of the chain waited longer than 38 minutes at any time in the second year
  • DThe chain's clinics were open on the same number of days in each of the two years

Step-by-Step Solution

The chain's average is the three clinics' waits weighted by how many patients each saw, so it can fall without a single clinic quickening if patients simply shift away from the slow one — a bus route altered, a clinic closed a day a week, a new road bringing patients to the fastest branch. The partner's conclusion therefore rests on the mix having stayed put, and denying that assumption dissolves his case. Each clinic seeing more patients is neither needed nor helpful, since the mix could still shift. No patient waiting above 38 minutes would make 38 an unusually high average rather than a mean. And equal opening days leave the distribution of patients across the three untouched.
Answer: A) The share of the chain's patients seen at its slowest clinic was not appreciably smaller in the second year than in the first

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A forest division judges its plantation work by the number of saplings put into the…An electricity utility judges its repair wing by the share of consumer complaints closed…A district administration pays villagers thirty rupees for every sack of uprooted water…Statement: A trust hospital pays its pathology laboratory a fixed share of the fee…A block officer's note reads: 'Across the block's ninety villages, the more irrigated…