Practice30Create account

A city corporation posted four extra sweepers to each of the ten wards that had recorded the largest number of sanitation complaints in June. Over July the complaints from those ten wards fell by a third, and the corporation concludes that the extra sweepers brought them down. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the corporation's conclusion?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe extra sweepers were engaged on daily wages rather than added to the corporation's regular staff
  • BComplaints in the corporation's remaining wards stood a little higher in July than in June
  • CA ward's monthly complaint count swings widely for reasons of its own, and in each of the past five years the ten wards standing highest in any one month have recorded far fewer complaints the month after without a single extra sweeper being posted
  • DComplaints are received at the ward office and entered in a register kept by the sanitary inspector

Step-by-Step Solution

The ten wards were not picked at random; they were picked because June was an extreme month for them. A count that swings about a ward's own usual figure will, when it has just been at its highest, ordinarily be lower next month whatever anyone does, and five years of that pattern show the July fall was waiting to happen. How the sweepers were paid touches nothing. A slight rise elsewhere would, if anything, support the corporation rather than damage it. Where complaints are entered was the same in both months and cannot explain a change in either.
Answer: C) A ward's monthly complaint count swings widely for reasons of its own, and in each of the past five years the ten wards standing highest in any one month have recorded far fewer complaints the month after without a single extra sweeper being posted

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

The head of a school sends, after each monthly test, the thirty pupils whose marks were…A district health office sent a mobile van for six months to the twelve sub-centres at…An industries officer studied the fifty small units that have worked without a break for…A fisheries association's bulletin states: 'Every one of the boat crews that came…An agriculture office holds that keeping a written account of what a season's crop costs…