Practice30Create account

A courier hub fitted new sorting racks in January, and the number of parcels entered in its register as mis-sent fell sharply over the six months that followed. The hub supervisor treats this as evidence that the racks have reduced sorting mistakes. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the supervisor's reasoning?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AIn that same January the hub handed its two largest delivery zones over to a second hub, and mis-sent parcels on those zones — which had made up most of this hub's recorded mistakes — are now entered against the second hub instead
  • BThe racks were bought from a supplier the hub had dealt with before
  • CSorting staff needed a few days to grow used to working with the new racks
  • DThe hub handles a greater weight of parcels in December than in any other month

Step-by-Step Solution

The mistakes that made up most of the earlier count are simply no longer being counted here; they have moved to another register, not out of existence. The fall in this hub's figure is fully accounted for by that transfer, so it is no evidence at all about how well the racks work. The supplier's identity, a few days of unfamiliarity and December volumes leave the register's contents untouched.
Answer: A) In that same January the hub handed its two largest delivery zones over to a second hub, and mis-sent parcels on those zones — which had made up most of this hub's recorded mistakes — are now entered against the second hub instead

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A branch library began posting a reminder to each borrower three days before a book…A poultry unit changed the feed given in one shed, and the birds in that shed reached…After a pedestrian crossing with a raised table was built outside a school gate, the…A plant nursery watered one season's seedlings by a slow drip instead of by hand, and…A hospital laundry changed its detergent, and the share of linen bundles turned back by…