Practice30Create account

A district agriculture office argues that its 300-rupee soil test is worth the money to every grower of the tract, since the additional yield the tract's growers obtained after testing, averaged over them, came to far more than 300 rupees a grower. Which of the following is an assumption on which the office's argument depends?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe additional yield was not confined to so few growers that the great body of those who paid the 300 rupees gained little or nothing by it
  • BThe office made no profit on the fee it charged for the test
  • CEvery grower of the tract had his soil tested
  • DThe tract's crop failed in more than one of the past five years

Step-by-Step Solution

The office moves from an average benefit to a benefit for every grower, and that passage holds only if the benefit is fairly evenly spread. Suppose one grower in twenty had a badly deficient field, gained twenty thousand rupees by correcting it, and the rest gained nothing: the average would still stand far above 300 and nineteen growers in twenty would have wasted their money. The argument therefore assumes the gain is not bunched in that way. Whether the office profits on the fee bears on the office's motive and not on the grower's return. That every grower was tested is neither needed nor claimed, since the office is recommending the test to those who have not had it. And past crop failures describe the tract's fortunes without bearing on how this year's gain was distributed.
Answer: A) The additional yield was not confined to so few growers that the great body of those who paid the 300 rupees gained little or nothing by it

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A district administration's report holds that its de-weeding of the main canal before…The owner of a cold store advertises that of the potato lots his store held last year…A state tourism board reports that 1.4 lakh visitors came to the district's limestone…The manager of a district employment exchange reports that 6,200 of those on the…A district road safety cell reports: 'Our helmet talks were attended 4,800 times at the…