Practice30Create account

A state tourism board reports that 1.4 lakh visitors came to the district's limestone caves last year, the first full year after the board's advertisements for the caves began, and concludes that the advertisements brought the visitors to the caves. Which of the following is an assumption on which the board's conclusion depends?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe board's advertisements for the caves were published in more than one language
  • BThe 1.4 lakh visitors include a substantial number who came from outside the state
  • CThe board keeps its own count of visitors at the mouth of the caves
  • DAppreciably fewer than 1.4 lakh visitors would have come to the caves last year had the advertisements not been published

Step-by-Step Solution

A figure for the year after the advertisements shows what happened; it does not show what the advertisements did, and it cannot until it is set against what would have happened without them. If the caves drew 1.5 lakh in each of the three preceding years, the advertisements have cost money and lost visitors, and the board's conclusion is not merely unproved but false. The assumption is therefore precisely the missing comparison-point. The languages of the advertisements bear on their reach; where the visitors came from bears on the district's market; and who keeps the count bears on the figure's accuracy. Each of the three could be settled in the board's favour and the conclusion would still hang on a year that has never been weighed against any other.
Answer: D) Appreciably fewer than 1.4 lakh visitors would have come to the caves last year had the advertisements not been published

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

The manager of a district employment exchange reports that 6,200 of those on the…A district road safety cell reports: 'Our helmet talks were attended 4,800 times at the…A city corporation reports that the free swimming lessons at its two pools were attended…A state department reports that 40,000 households of the district hold a job card,…Statement: A city's three hospitals report 1,100, 800 and 600 admissions for dengue over…