Practice30Create account

A farmers' producer company put a question in its monthly bulletin and on its notice board asking members whether the company should set up a turmeric boiling and polishing unit. Of the 260 members who answered, 71 in every hundred said it should, and the board concludes that most of the company's 2,400 members want the unit. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the board's conclusion?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AA unit of the size proposed would cost the company about 90 lakh rupees to build and equip
  • BAlmost all of the 260 who answered grow turmeric, which the unit would take, while the great body of the company's members grow maize and cotton, which it would not
  • CThe company's monthly bulletin is carried by post to the house of every member
  • DThe company was registered four years ago and has admitted new members in each year since

Step-by-Step Solution

The 260 are not a slice of the membership but the members with a stake in the answer, and the option names the stake: the unit would serve their crop and no other. A body of respondents assembled by their own interest in the proposal will of course approve it, and their approval carries no weight for the maize and cotton growers who never troubled to reply. The cost of the unit bears on whether it should be built even if wanted — a separate question the board must also answer. That the bulletin reaches every house strengthens the board rather than weakening it, since it removes the excuse that members never saw the question and leaves their silence a choice. The company's age and its intake of members describe its history and bear on neither the 260 nor the 2,400.
Answer: B) Almost all of the 260 who answered grow turmeric, which the unit would take, while the great body of the company's members grow maize and cotton, which it would not

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A city corporation opened a telephone line on which residents might record whether the…The organisers of a town's flower show left a card at every stall asking visitors to…An education department's note sets the reading of Class 5 pupils in the district's…A state warehousing corporation reports that its Rampur godown lost far fewer bags to…A minor irrigation wing reports that the tanks in its own charge stood fuller at the…