Practice30Create account

A town's fire office fitted new hydrants along the market street in March, and reports that the value of goods lost to fire in the twelve months that followed was well below the value lost in the twelve months before. An answer to which of the following questions would be of most use in judging whether the hydrants are what brought the loss down?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AWhat did the new hydrants cost to fit?
  • BHow many hydrants were fitted along the market street?
  • CAre the hydrants of the pattern used elsewhere in the state?
  • DIn which month did the loss begin to fall, and how did the monthly loss stand over the months before March?

Step-by-Step Solution

Two twelve-month totals hide the one thing that decides the question: whether the fall started when the hydrants went in. If the monthly loss had been dropping since the previous autumn, the hydrants arrived in the middle of something already happening and cannot be credited with it; if it dropped from March and not before, the case is strong. What the hydrants cost bears on value for money, how many were fitted describes the works, and their pattern would matter only if it were the design that were in question.
Answer: D) In which month did the loss begin to fall, and how did the monthly loss stand over the months before March?

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

Statement: The block's tube wells are repaired only after sowing has begun, and standing…A water board's note reads: 'Piped connections in the district have grown by 3,000…The owner of a day-care has taken premises four times the size of her present ones. She…A spinning unit's manager reports that the unit's electricity use fell by 12 in every…A town's rubbish tip took twenty years to fill one half of its pit. At the rate at which…