Practice30Create account

A transport office notes that its northern depot recorded 18 accidents last year while its southern depot recorded 9, and concludes that the drivers of the northern depot are the less careful of the two. In setting the two figures side by side, the office takes for granted which of the following?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThat an accident at either depot was entered in the register on the day it occurred
  • BThat the northern depot employs more drivers than the southern depot does
  • CThat no accident at either depot involved a vehicle from outside the depot's own fleet
  • DThat the two counts arise from a similar amount of driving, so that the larger count is not simply the result of the northern depot's buses covering far more kilometres in the year

Step-by-Step Solution

Two bare counts can be set against each other only if they come from the same amount of exposure. If the northern buses run three times the distance, 18 accidents would show better care than 9, not worse, and the office's verdict reverses. Prompt entry in the register, the number of drivers on the roll and the fleets involved would each leave that gap between the two figures exactly where it is.
Answer: D) That the two counts arise from a similar amount of driving, so that the larger count is not simply the result of the northern depot's buses covering far more kilometres in the year

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A hospital administrator reports that the average wait in the eye department is 22…The owner of a stationery shop notes that the shop took 9.2 lakh rupees in the year just…A library trust observes that its town branch issued 14,000 books last year while its…A workshop buys drive belting by the metre. The purchase clerk argues that the belting…An orchard owner argues that he should replace his old guava trees with a new variety,…