Practice30Create account

An association of private schools has published a study which lays down that no study of school quality is to be trusted unless it is made by a body with no interest in the answer, and which concludes that the district's private schools teach better than its government schools. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the association's conclusion?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe district's government schools hold about three times as many pupils as its private schools
  • BThe study was carried out by the association itself, a body established to advance the standing of the district's private schools
  • CThe study was set out in a bulletin of thirty pages
  • DSome of the district's private schools charge a fee that few households of the district could pay

Step-by-Step Solution

The study announces a test for trustworthy studies and then fails it: the body that made it exists to raise the standing of one of the two kinds of school it was weighing. The conclusion is therefore untrustworthy by the association's own rule, and no separate charge of dishonesty is needed to reach that result. The relative numbers of pupils describe the district's schooling without bearing on who made the study or how. The length of the bulletin is a fact about the printing. And that some private schools are dear bears on who can reach them, which is an objection to private schooling as a policy and not to the study's finding about teaching.
Answer: B) The study was carried out by the association itself, a body established to advance the standing of the district's private schools

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

Statement: A town's water board has told its consumers that the meter readings taken by…Statement: 'Please switch off your mobile phones during the meeting' — a notice at the…Statement: 'Use our coaching program to improve your reasoning score' — an…Statement I: The school administration declared a holiday on account of heavy rainfall…Statement: A large number of students failed the mathematics examination this year.…