Practice30Create account

The secretary of a handloom weavers' society tells the general body: 'Every piece we carry to the two exhibitions we attend each year is sold before the exhibition closes. The society should therefore weave twice as many pieces in the coming year.' Which of the following is an assumption on which the secretary's argument depends?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe society's weavers are paid for each piece woven rather than for each day worked
  • BThe cloth carried to the exhibitions is woven on the society's own looms and not bought in from other weavers
  • CThe two exhibitions are held in different months of the year
  • DBuyers can be found for the additional pieces, whether at the exhibitions or elsewhere — that what is carried to two exhibitions sells out does not of itself show that twice as much cloth would be bought

Step-by-Step Solution

Selling out shows that the society carried no more than the exhibitions would absorb; it does not show how much more they would have absorbed, and it says nothing at all about the rest of the year. The step from a sold-out stall to a doubled year's output therefore rests on the additional cloth finding a buyer somewhere, and if it does not the society will have doubled its yarn bill and its wages to fill a godown. How the weavers are paid bears on what the doubling would cost, not on whether the cloth would sell. Where the cloth is woven bears on who profits by the sale. And the months in which the exhibitions fall would matter to the society's cash flow while leaving the size of the market exactly where the secretary found it.
Answer: D) Buyers can be found for the additional pieces, whether at the exhibitions or elsewhere — that what is carried to two exhibitions sells out does not of itself show that twice as much cloth would be bought

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A fire officer's note reads: 'Of the calls the station attended last year, the engine…The manager of a district's fair price shop network argues: 'Our door-step delivery has…A food inspector's note reads: 'Since the new testing order came into force, seizures of…A city corporation reports that in the six months since the sorting of household waste…A district transport officer argues: 'Our learner's licence test has grown stricter.…