Practice30Create account

A post office argues: 'Opening a separate counter for parcels will shorten the queue at the letter counter, because at present everyone stands in the one line whatever business he has come on.' Which of the following, if it turned out to be FALSE, would most damage the argument?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AA substantial share of the people now standing in the single line have come to send parcels
  • BThe post office is open on Saturday mornings
  • CParcels posted at this office are collected by a van each evening
  • DThe letter counter is staffed by one clerk at a time

Step-by-Step Solution

A parcel counter shortens the remaining queue only by drawing people out of it. If parcel senders are a handful, almost everybody stays where he is and the letter queue is barely touched, so this is the claim the argument leans on hardest. Saturday hours, the evening collection van and the number of clerks could each be false while the argument still stood.
Answer: A) A substantial share of the people now standing in the single line have come to send parcels

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A hostel warden argues: 'Replacing the water heater with one of twice its size will put…The owner of a bookbinding unit argues: 'Buying a second trimming press will double the…A sugar mill's cane development officer notes that growers who attend the mill's monthly…A district trade body finds that shops in the cloth market which employ a night watchman…At a district kabaddi academy the trainer observes that players who use the ice bath…