Practice30Create account

A sugar mill's cane development officer notes that growers who attend the mill's monthly field meeting harvest about eleven tonnes more cane a hectare than growers who never attend, and concludes that what is said at the meeting raises a grower's yield. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the officer's conclusion?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe field meeting is conducted in the growers' own language rather than in English
  • BThe list of growers invited to the meeting is drawn up afresh each year by the mill's field staff from those whose previous harvest was among the heaviest in the area, so a grower is called to the meeting because his yield is already high
  • CA few of the growers who attend the meeting also supply cane to a second mill in the neighbouring district
  • DThe mill has held the field meeting on the first Tuesday of every month for the past eleven years

Step-by-Step Solution

The officer reads the gap between the two groups as the meeting acting on the grower. But if a heavy harvest is what earns a grower his invitation, the gap was there before the meeting was ever attended, and the meeting is the consequence of the yield rather than its source. The language used at the meeting, a few growers' dealings with a second mill and the eleven years of first Tuesdays leave the two groups exactly as unlike as they already were.
Answer: B) The list of growers invited to the meeting is drawn up afresh each year by the mill's field staff from those whose previous harvest was among the heaviest in the area, so a grower is called to the meeting because his yield is already high

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A district trade body finds that shops in the cloth market which employ a night watchman…At a district kabaddi academy the trainer observes that players who use the ice bath…The supervisor of a tailoring unit finds that the operators whose tables are tidiest at…A hill town's tourism committee argues that listing every guest house in the town on one…A tehsil office proposes to hold a 'meet the officer' hour on Saturday evenings,…