Practice30Create account

A tehsil office proposes to hold a 'meet the officer' hour on Saturday evenings, pointing out that when the neighbouring tehsil began doing so the number of grievances settled within a month rose by half. Which of the following, if true, gives the strongest reason to doubt that the same result will follow here?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AIn the neighbouring tehsil nearly all those who bring grievances live in the town where the office stands, whereas four in five of the people who bring grievances to this office live in villages from which the last bus home leaves at half past four
  • BThe neighbouring tehsil's office building is older than this one
  • CThis tehsil contains slightly fewer villages than the neighbouring tehsil contains
  • DThe officer who introduced the evening hour in the neighbouring tehsil has since been transferred elsewhere

Step-by-Step Solution

An evening hour works only if the people it is meant for can still be there in the evening, and that is exactly what held in the neighbouring tehsil and fails here. Most of this tehsil's complainants must be on the last bus before the hour begins, so the room would stand empty. The age of a building, a small difference in the number of villages and the transfer of one officer leave the borrowed result untouched.
Answer: A) In the neighbouring tehsil nearly all those who bring grievances live in the town where the office stands, whereas four in five of the people who bring grievances to this office live in villages from which the last bus home leaves at half past four

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A silk-reeling cluster is being urged to build a shared tank in which waste water can be…A block education officer writes: 'The evening study centre raised the share of pupils…The owner of a printing press argues: 'Orders are waiting that we cannot take on. A…The secretary of a growers' cooperative urges that the whole of the society's reserve be…A town engineer writes: 'A footbridge over the level crossing would take away every risk…