Practice30Create account

A hill town's tourism committee argues that listing every guest house in the town on one shared web page will raise bookings here, because the town on the next ridge did exactly that and its bookings doubled within a season. Which of the following is an assumption on which the committee's argument depends?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe shared web page can be built for no more than the neighbouring town spent on its own
  • BThe number of travellers who reach this town in a season is exactly equal to the number who reach the town on the next ridge
  • CWhat holds bookings down in this town is, as it was on the next ridge, that travellers cannot find out which houses take guests, and not something a listing cannot touch, such as the state of the road up to the town
  • DThe committee of the neighbouring town has no objection to its idea being taken up here

Step-by-Step Solution

The whole force of the argument is that the neighbouring town's result can be carried across, and a result travels only with the condition that produced it. If bookings here are held down by a broken road rather than by ignorance of who takes guests, the listing removes an obstacle this town does not have. What the page costs is a question of affordability rather than of effect, equal traveller numbers is a far stronger claim than the argument needs, and the neighbours' goodwill is beside the point.
Answer: C) What holds bookings down in this town is, as it was on the next ridge, that travellers cannot find out which houses take guests, and not something a listing cannot touch, such as the state of the road up to the town

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A tehsil office proposes to hold a 'meet the officer' hour on Saturday evenings,…A silk-reeling cluster is being urged to build a shared tank in which waste water can be…A block education officer writes: 'The evening study centre raised the share of pupils…The owner of a printing press argues: 'Orders are waiting that we cannot take on. A…The secretary of a growers' cooperative urges that the whole of the society's reserve be…