Practice30Create account

The welfare officer of a jute mill holds that the covers fitted over the spinning frames last year are what brought down the number of workers reporting the dry cough. Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the officer's position?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AThe covers were paid for out of the mill's own funds and not from any grant
  • BWorkers at the mill are examined by a doctor once every year
  • CAir sampled at head height beside the frames showed the loose fibre it carried fall by two-thirds in the week the covers went on, and it is the breathing in of that fibre which brings on the cough in question
  • DThe covers were made in the mill's own repair shed rather than bought in

Step-by-Step Solution

The officer asserts a link between a cover and a cough with nothing in between; the option supplies the missing middle, showing that the covers cut the airborne fibre and that this fibre is what causes the cough. With both steps in place the claim rests on a working chain rather than on coincidence. How the covers were funded and where they were made bear on cost and provenance, and a yearly medical examination was in place before and after alike.
Answer: C) Air sampled at head height beside the frames showed the loose fibre it carried fall by two-thirds in the week the covers went on, and it is the breathing in of that fibre which brings on the cough in question

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

The manager of a wedding hall holds that the token counter he set up at the door of the…A district agriculture office holds that the recorded voice call warning growers of a…A city corporation posted four extra sweepers to each of the ten wards that had recorded…The head of a school sends, after each monthly test, the thirty pupils whose marks were…A district health office sent a mobile van for six months to the twelve sub-centres at…