Practice30Create account

A ward office asked 300 people leaving the vegetable market on a Sunday morning whether the market's hours should be extended into the evening. Four in five said yes, and the office announced that the ward wants longer market hours. Which of the following, if true, would do most to show that the 300 replies can support a claim about the ward as a whole?

Competition practiceLogical / Critical
  • AEach of the 300 people was asked the question in the same words
  • BThe market is the largest of the three markets in the ward
  • CNone of the 300 people approached refused to answer
  • DA survey taken in the same month at households across the ward, including many that never visit the market, produced the same four-in-five split on the question

Step-by-Step Solution

The doubt about the 300 is that people found leaving a market on a Sunday morning are exactly the people most attached to it, so their answers need not stand for the ward. Independent evidence from households across the ward, non-visitors included, that lands on the same four in five is what shows the narrow group happened to mirror the wide one. Uniform wording, the market's size and a full response rate all leave the group as unrepresentative as it was.
Answer: D) A survey taken in the same month at households across the ward, including many that never visit the market, produced the same four-in-five split on the question

Master this topic in 30 minutes a day.

Don't just memorise the answer — build a daily practice habit.

Practice 5 Similar Questions Free →

All Logical / Critical practice questions

More Logical / Critical practice

A clinic treated 300 patients for a skin complaint and asked each of them to return…A depot checked 60 of the 600 tyres held in its store, picking them by a method that…A safety officer argues: 'Fitting a second water tank on the roof of the warehouse will…A post office argues: 'Opening a separate counter for parcels will shorten the queue at…A hostel warden argues: 'Replacing the water heater with one of twice its size will put…